Why Difficult Conversations Are Core HR Work
Difficult conversations are not occasional disruptions to normal HR work. They are a central part of the job. The SHRM Body of Applied Skills and Knowledge (BASK) addresses difficult conversations within the Communication and Relationship Management competencies, and both the SHRM-CP and SHRM-SCP exams include situational judgment items that test your ability to handle these conversations effectively.
The cost of avoiding difficult conversations is high. Performance issues that are not addressed grow worse over time. Conflicts that are not mediated escalate. Harassment that is not confronted creates legal liability and harms employees.
Preparing for Difficult Conversations
Clarify Your Objectives
Before entering a difficult conversation, be clear about what you want to accomplish. Are you delivering a decision (such as a termination)? Are you trying to change behavior? Are you gathering information (such as investigating a complaint)? Your objective shapes how you structure the conversation.
Gather Facts
Ground the conversation in facts rather than opinions or hearsay. If you are discussing a performance issue, have specific examples with dates, details, and documented impact.
Anticipate Reactions
Think through how the other person is likely to react and prepare for different scenarios. They might become angry, defensive, tearful, or withdrawn. Plan what you will say if they deny the facts, become emotional, or try to deflect.
Plan Your Opening
The first 30 seconds set the tone for everything that follows. Prepare a clear, direct opening statement that identifies the purpose without being unnecessarily harsh. Avoid starting with small talk or positive comments that create false expectations.
During the Conversation
Stay Focused on Facts and Behavior
Describe specific behaviors and their impact rather than making character judgments. Instead of "You have a bad attitude," say "In the last three team meetings, you interrupted colleagues six times and made dismissive comments about their ideas."
Listen Actively
Even in conversations where you are delivering a decision, the other person deserves to be heard. Allow them to respond, ask questions, and express their perspective.
Manage Emotions
Stay calm and professional even if the other person becomes emotional. Never raise your voice, use sarcasm, or respond to hostility with hostility.
Document the Conversation
Take notes or prepare a written summary immediately after the conversation. Documentation should include the date, time, attendees, key topics discussed, commitments made, and the employee's response.
Practice your approach with our diagnostic assessment.
Specific Types of Difficult Conversations
Termination meetings. Be direct and clear. The decision has been made, so do not present it as a discussion. Explain the reason briefly, provide information about severance and benefits continuation, and treat the person with dignity. Have a witness present.
Performance improvement conversations. Focus on specific performance gaps, the expected standard, and available support. Set clear, measurable goals with a defined timeline. Document everything in a PIP.
Harassment and discrimination complaints. Listen carefully and take detailed notes. Explain the investigation process and anti-retaliation protections. Do not make promises about specific outcomes.
Layoff and restructuring announcements. Communicate the business reasons honestly. Explain the selection criteria and process. Provide information about severance, benefits continuation, and outplacement services.
Conflict mediation. Establish ground rules. Allow each party to share their perspective without interruption. Identify common interests. Focus on solutions rather than blame.
After the Conversation
- Document the conversation promptly while details are fresh
- Follow through on any commitments you made
- Monitor the situation for improvement, retaliation, or escalation
- Provide ongoing support where appropriate
- Debrief with your own support network (while maintaining confidentiality)
Build a study plan covering communication skills and all SHRM competencies using our study schedule builder.
Start Practicing Today
Difficult conversations are among the most important and most tested skills on the SHRM exams.
Create your free account to access situational judgment practice questions covering difficult conversations, conflict management, and SHRM communication competencies.