Why Function Matters More Than Form
Behavior analysts classify behavior by its function, meaning the relation between the behavior and the environmental events that maintain it, rather than by its topography, meaning what it looks like. Two children can both hit a peer, yet one hits to gain attention while the other hits to escape a demand. The same intervention will not help both. This is why functional behavior assessment (FBA) is the starting point for treating problem behavior.
The Four Functions
Most textbooks describe four functions, which fall into two broad groups. Socially mediated functions are maintained by consequences delivered by other people. Automatic functions are maintained by consequences produced directly by the behavior.
1. Attention (socially mediated positive reinforcement)
Behavior is maintained by social attention such as praise, reprimands, eye contact, or conversation. Note that a reprimand can be a reinforcer if it increases behavior. Example: a student shouts out during a lesson, the teacher turns and says "Quiet please," and shouting continues to occur at a high rate.
- Typical antecedent: The person is not receiving attention, or attention is directed elsewhere.
- Typical consequence: Attention is delivered.
2. Escape (socially mediated negative reinforcement)
Behavior is maintained by removal or delay of an aversive event, such as a task demand, a person, or a noisy environment. Example: a learner throws materials when given a difficult worksheet, the worksheet is taken away, and throwing becomes more likely when worksheets appear.
- Typical antecedent: A demand or aversive stimulus is presented.
- Typical consequence: The demand is removed or reduced.
3. Access to tangibles (socially mediated positive reinforcement)
Behavior is maintained by access to preferred items or activities. Example: a child cries when a tablet is taken away and receives it back. Crying will be more likely the next time the tablet is removed.
- Typical antecedent: A preferred item is unavailable or has been removed.
- Typical consequence: The item is provided.
4. Automatic reinforcement
Behavior is maintained by sensory consequences produced by the behavior itself, independent of other people. Example: a child repeatedly spins objects and continues to do so when alone and no demands are present. Automatic reinforcement can be positive (producing a pleasant sensation) or negative (reducing an unpleasant one, such as scratching to relieve itching).
- Typical pattern: The behavior occurs across conditions, including when the person is alone.
Assessing Function
An FBA typically uses three types of methods, and the BCBA exam expects you to know their strengths and limits.
- Indirect assessment: Interviews and rating scales such as the Questions About Behavioral Function (QABF). These are quick and useful for generating hypotheses but are not very reliable on their own.
- Descriptive assessment: Direct observation of behavior in the natural environment, including ABC data and scatterplots. These show correlations but cannot demonstrate a functional relation.
- Functional analysis: Systematic manipulation of antecedents and consequences in test conditions (attention, escape, tangible, alone, and a control play condition) to demonstrate a functional relation. This is the only method that demonstrates control.
When a traditional functional analysis is risky, variations such as brief functional analysis, latency-based analysis, or trial-based functional analysis may be used. Safety and ethics always come first.
Writing a Hypothesis Statement
A good hypothesis includes the setting event or antecedent, the observable behavior, and the maintaining consequence. For example: "When given a multistep math worksheet, Jamal tears the paper and leaves his seat, which results in the worksheet being removed. The function is escape from academic demands." Avoid vague statements such as "Jamal is seeking control."
Linking Function to Treatment
Once the function is known, interventions should address it directly.
- Attention: Teach appropriate ways to request attention, provide noncontingent attention on a time-based schedule, and place problem behavior on extinction when safe.
- Escape: Teach a break request, modify task difficulty, use demand fading, and ensure escape extinction is used cautiously and ethically.
- Tangible: Teach mands for items, use waiting routines, and provide noncontingent access.
- Automatic: Provide competing stimulation, enrich the environment, or teach alternative behaviors that produce similar sensory input.
Functional communication training (FCT) is a common intervention that teaches a replacement response that serves the same function as the problem behavior. The replacement must be as efficient as, or more efficient than, the problem behavior.
Multiple and Changing Functions
Behavior can be multiply controlled. A child might scream to escape some demands and to get attention in other contexts. Functions can also shift over time, which is why ongoing data and periodic reassessment are required. A hypothesis is treated as a working statement and is revised when the data say so.
Common Exam Traps
- Do not choose a function based on the form of the behavior. Self-injury can be maintained by any of the four functions.
- An escape function involves negative reinforcement, not punishment.
- Descriptive data cannot confirm function; only a functional analysis can.
- If behavior occurs at high rates in the alone condition, suspect automatic reinforcement.
- Extinction should match the function. Ignoring behavior maintained by escape will not be extinction.
Practice Scenario
A client engages in head banging in the playroom. During a functional analysis, head banging is high in the demand condition and near zero in the play condition. What is the likely function? Escape. The best next step is to design an intervention that includes FCT for requesting breaks, demand fading, and reinforcement for task completion.
Key Takeaways
The four functions are attention, escape, tangible, and automatic reinforcement. Function is determined by consequences, confirmed with functional analysis, and used to choose function-based treatment such as FCT. Treat the function, not just the topography.